Skip to main content

How Do I Say Goodbye?

Wendy called.  She had heard about Tom's passing and the enormous peace that filled our hearts and home.  My friend challenged:  "Mary, you've got to share your story on your blog.  You will encourage other families going through hard times."  Of course, I knew she was right.  The Lord has been nudging me too.  "I want to heal families, He told me. Tell your story."   My daughters join me, from two different perspectives, to share our family's journey of faith as we navigate through the night we lost our patriarch.  Our hope is in Jesus Christ who comforts our souls.  Here are their thoughts.  

Carrie Writes:

In our family, we have often said that God can use you and change your story until your last breath. I always believed that, and then I saw it with my own two eyes.

I was never the peacemaker in the family. That role belonged to my sister and mother. I was the feisty one. The one that wasn’t going to put up with bad behavior. My dad had mental illness. Where my mother and sister continually gave him a pass, I harbored resentment and anger being raised by a dad like that. It got worse into my adulthood, and I learned to cope by keeping him at arm’s length. I loved my dad, but loving a person with mental illness is complicated. The day he died, God made it uncomplicated. He told me to forgive him.

On the early morning of May 30th, 2022, I could hear it in my mom’s voice on the phone that I needed to get there that day. I live 4 hours away and had been there the week before. I had said a heartfelt goodbye to my dad at the end of that visit and had reconciled that I would probably never see him again. He was in hospice and was last stage pancreatic cancer. He had stopped all chemo treatments the weeks before. It was just too much.

I loaded up my car that Sunday and arrived about noon. My sister, sleep deprived and emotionally spent, collapsed into my arms and wept. Mom did the same. Then they both took long naps and I took over med duty, and held Dad’s hand for hours. Dad was non communicative at this point but he gave me two long blinks as I told him he didn’t have anything to worry about, we were going to take good care of Mom. Mostly we just sat quietly until the death rattle began.

I knew that cancer had a bad end, but I admit that I did not research it, and was not prepared for what I would see and hear that day. Hospice was not available because they were short-staffed and it was Memorial Day weekend. We were on our own to navigate these final traumatic hours.

Listening to Dad’s labored breathing was extremely difficult, but I stayed next to him, holding his hand. It began to soften me towards him. All of the harbored anger and resentment left. I just desperately wanted peace for him.

I picked up the pamphlet Hospice had given Mom. It talked about what to expect in the final weeks, days, hours and minutes. It said that sometimes a dying person will hold on because 1) They are afraid to die, or 2) They feel they have unfinished business. The second I read that, I heard the Holy Spirit say, “Tell Dad you forgive him.”

I was alone with Dad and I leaned over him and said, “Dad…I forgive you. I forgive you for all of it. You have no unfinished business here.” The second after, his eyes got wide and his breathing changed and became even more intense. I called for Mom and my sister to come. We all held his hand and stroked his hair. He passed four minutes later.

It was silent for the first time in the house. No more oxygen tanks, no more death rattle breathing. Peace filled the home. We held his hands for several more minutes and leaned into the moment. God used my Dad’s last breaths to bring reconciliation between us.

Amy writes:

How do you say goodbye to a parent? That is something I still ponder. Did I tell him enough about how much I loved him? Did I convey all I wanted to say? Did I provide him the care he needed from me?  Will I regret all the things that I forgot to ask him about? How would I know what to ask? Who prepares you for this? I'm winging it here.

I didn't know at the time he contacted me by phone asking me to leave work and be with him, that it was the last week of his life.  He needed me at his side.  He begged me to come and be with him as soon as possible. Did he know death was near? 

He was having daily panic attacks about random things.  He kept worrying about Mom's state of mind. He voiced his fears about this cancer that had taken over and significantly changed his body. He asked me if I would clean him if he was no longer able to manage bowel movements. Of course I would   I never gave it a second thought.  I reassured him in those last few days.   

I didn't know it was going to be this hard.   Physically, his body was hard to look at.  His eyes sunk into his head and his color was yellow and ashen.  I didn't know he was going to resist the care I offered, or pull off his oxygen and tell me he wished he had died the night before. 

He stopped taking his oral meds. I could not convince him to take them otherwise. He was very uncomfortable, his movements and facial expressions demonstrated this.  He didn't cooperate; it was the worst version of my father I had ever observed.  I didn't recognize him.   

Am I doing all the right things? Could I have done more?  During the last two days of his life, I had not slept; I stayed at his side around the clock. How much longer did we have? Could I continue to care for him?   I was starting to notice my body trembling, I was emotionally fragile doing all I could to hold it together to be strong for my mother and for him. It was in those final hours of his life my sister arrived from Tucson. Dad was holding my hand when she walked in the door, upon hearing her voice he squeezed my hand twice acknowledging her arrival. 

I remember her embracing me as she greeted me.  The tears began to pour out of my eyes and I began to sob, my body trembling.  I cannot remember a time I had sobbed like this, if ever.  She held me tight and provided the reassurance I needed affirming me of her willingness to help. 

My heart was breaking for the inevitable loss approaching and rejoicing for the arrival of support and strength.  

In his last hours of existence, we had resorted to sublingual administration of medication. Using a dropper we gave Dad his medication under the tongue or in the side of his mouth. We only had two medications to work with, Morphine for pain and Lorazepam for anxiety.  Carrie, my sister sent me to bed as she could see I was a shell of a human.  I slept 3 hours, I was grateful as I had peace knowing she would care for him. Upon awakening, I recognized the sound of secretions in his airway; this was "the death rattle." It is the most disturbing and eerie sound. We knew his time was short. Mom was with us.  We tried to make him as comfortable as possible. We played soft worship music we knew he enjoyed.  We stayed near his bedside taking turns holding his hand, kissing his forehead, and telling him all the great things he was to us as a father and husband.  We verbalized our reassurance to him of how we would take care of Mom when he was gone.  

It was the eve of Memorial Day when he took his last breath around 8:55 pm. He had us promise him in the weeks beforehand we wouldn't cry upon his last breath.   "I won't be able to handle it," He had said.  So, we didn't cry.   Actually, we were in awe of the peace that surrounded us in those minutes that followed.   I have never felt that kind of tranquility.  There was silence.

It was calming to our souls.  We held each other and gave thanks to God.  The suffering had ended.  

Of all the hard things in life I have been through and experienced personally and professionally in the behavioral health field, this was one of the hardest for me.   

In days to follow, we had learned from the Chaplain that we had done the right things to help Dad make this transition. It was comforting to hear and brought us great delight.  

I thank God for giving me an opportunity to be there in those final days when he needed his family


  1. Dear Mary, I have sat here and struggled to keep shedding tears of real life that your daughter's are sharing with us. I finally gave in and just had a good cry! It was a much needed cry to begin with so reading their stories actually helped me. Our journeys in life can be complicated, sad and yet bring a much deeper meaning and a refreshment to our souls if we allow God to do as only He can do. I am learning this with each new journey in my life and it's hard at times. Thank you for sharing and Carrie and Amy's words of honestly, fear, sadness, struggle and yet joy of knowing their dad is no longer struggling with ANYTHING! I hope that you feel the many prayers of so many for you and your family. Hugs and blessings, Cindy

    1. We feel lifted up and carried by your prayers, my warrior friend! Thank you for crying with me and showing us so much compassion.

  2. Who can give us empathy & more compassion than the ones who experienced the same suffering, pain or broken hearts? Who is better able to tell how God can comfort others needing it but the ones who walked in that same dark valley?

    There's always a time that no matter how strong we are in the Lord, tears, pain and being wounded happen as we face storms of differing degrees. Sister Amy's and Carrie's letters brought up the same experience my brothers & I faced when my father passed away in 2007 from Colon Cancer. But I was sure glad that the Lord granted for us to be able to be with him and that, he was able to tell us what he wanted. As a nurse, I could relate to sister Amy's fears when bro Tom went to that breathing. That's what's difficult for us, nurses, that we could be so adept in caring for others. But when it comes to your own family, I would wish I didn't have the knowledge of foreboding things to occur.

    I could also relate and agree that peace from the Lord is none like other things here in this place. As we laughed more and cried but with joy, people who visited my ill father were wondering why we were happy instead of being sad. But my father & my siblings & I knew... It was His comfort and peace that eased the pain in our hearts. He was the One Who carried our burdens & strengthened us.

    I'm glad you shared this sister Mary though difficult it may be. But I know that you will bring comfort to those who needs this kind of reassurance because it is our good God Who is the Source of mercy & comfort.

    Even before I started reading your post, it was 2 Cor. 1:4 that was like being flashed in my mind.

    "" He comforts us in all our troubles so that we can comfort others. When they are troubled, we will be able to give them the same comfort God has given us. "🙏

    Thank you to sister Carrie reminding me of what forgiveness does... What healing! What freedom! What love! And to sister Amy who's always so caring & loving to your family especially for her parents. God bless you all, comfort you still, strengthen, heal, protect & probide for all of your needs. Love and 🙏 always from me sister!

    1. That 2 Cor. 1:4 verse is our goal. Now that we know the heartbreak let us extend the comfort we received. Just as you have done with us after your own experience. I always thank Almighty God for you, my precious sister.

  3. Provide!!! Just to correct my word there... It has been difficult for me to write a comment whether in my own blog or that of others' in other devices except my cell phone. Sorry...

  4. I appreciate your sharing Tom's last days before succumbing to the final call. May the soul of your husband and father to the two daughters rest in peace and protect his family from above!

    1. Thank you, Duta. I feel closer to Tom than ever!

  5. Tears! Thank you for showing us what courage and compassion is all about.

  6. I can only say that I believe absolutely that your father is in the most beautiful place that I was taken to in my near death experience, and the love that you gave him was the most important thing that you could do in his last hours.

  7. I am sorry Mary, I think I have got it wrong. It looks like it is your husband who has passed away but for some reason I thought it was your father. Please forgive me if I did get it wrong. God bless you with His peace and love in these sad times.

  8. Dropping by to wish you a great Sunday sister! Stay strong in the Lord's mighty power! Keep hydrated & cooled! 💧🚿... ♥️🙏

  9. Mary, I am so sorry to learn of your loss. I can relate to Amy, as I cared for my mom the last year and a half after her stroke til she passed in January this year. Everything Amy describes, I can relate to. Anyway, you, and Carrie and Amy will be in my prayers. (previously blogging at Our Sears Kit Home)


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Because He Lives, I Can Move

I’m currently in one of those places where you lay out all the options and then you make the best decision. It seems, however, like none of the choices are fair or attractive. I know God will help me in my situation because I desire His guidance. I’m clinging to His Word which promises that ALL things work together for good for those that love God and are called according to His purpose, Romans 8:28. I heard a great teaching this week about seeking God’s will and all the freedom that surrender brings. We can know that God is bringing about a victory if we trust Him with each and every decision. The speaker illustrated his point with a famous painting. The painting depicts a look of despair on the chess player’s face. He’s playing Satan and his soul is at stake. It looks like Satan is winning. Checkmate! When Paul Morphy saw this painting back in the 1800’s, he set up a chess board and aligned the pieces to reflect the painting. Being a world champion, he studied the board. His co

A Veteran's Story

  I noticed Bill sitting in our local park where I walk.   He glanced my way just as I finished the last exercise walk song on my playlist.   He shouted and pointed to my car:   “Hey, is that your car with the Nam front license plate?   I stepped closer into the veranda where Bill sat on a picnic bench.   I noticed his Vietnam Vet cap and instantly I knew why I walked there that day.   The Marine Vet served during the 1960’s, the same time span as my husband.   Bill talked a lot about the war evoking my emotions from laughter to tears.   My South Vietnam front plate often prompts a conversation with a stranger and I’ve learned a deep respect for it over the years.   It is my way of listening to a veteran.   I enjoyed listening to Bill.   He made me laugh in spots but he made me cry as well.   Like when he talked about the sandwich lady.   “Do you ever eat at the sandwich shop in the gas station down the street?”   I replied that I’ve order coffee once in that place with a turke

Because He Lives I Can Move

Reprinted from March, 2011 I’m currently in one of those places where I lay out all the options and try to make the best decision. It seems, however, like none of the choices are fair or attractive. I know God will help me in my situation; I’m praying for His guidance. I’m clinging to His Word which promises that ALL things work together for good for those that love God and are called according to His purpose, Romans 8:28. I heard a great teaching this week about seeking God’s will.  Surrender to God’s will brings freedom!  He wants me to trust Him for the victory. The speaker/teacher illustrated his point with a famous painting. The painting depicts a look of despair on the chess player’s face. He’s playing Satan and his soul is at stake. It looks like Satan is winning. Checkmate! When Paul Morphy saw this painting back in the 1800’s, he set up a chess board and aligned the chess pieces to match the painting. Being a world champion, he studied the board. He